An motor celi ſit immobilis firmatꝰ circa terrā

tratēdere māſione qͣꝫ terra ſortitur manens. autmouebitur terra a medio ⁊ ex ꝓprio loco. Sicut em̄ pellens pellit. ſic pulſum pellitur et ſimul ẜm virtutem. mouet aūt quieſcens primūquare magna et amplior virtus et ſimilis et equalis quieti. Similiter aūt et moti quidem.nō mouētis aūt. tantam ergo oportebit virtutēeſſe terre in qͥeſcēdo. quātam totū celum habꝫet mouēs ip̄m Si aūt hoc impoſſibile. impoſibile moueri et celuꝫ ab aliquo tali eorū que interra Eſt aūt quedā dubitatō circa motus partiū celi. quaꝫ vt exiſtētē cōueniētē dictis cōſiderabit vtiqꝫ quis. Si em̄ aliquis excedat virtute motus terre quieteꝫ palā quia mouebit ipſaꝫa medio et virtus aūt a qua hic potentia ꝙ nōinfinita manifeſtū. neqꝫ em̄ terra infinita. quare neqꝫ grauitas ipſius. Quoniā aūt impoſſibile dicitur multipliciter Nō em̄ ſimiliter dicimus vocē eſſe impoſſibile videri. et eos qui inluna a nobis. hoc qͥdem em̄ ex neceſſitate. hocaūt natu videri nō videbitur. Celū aūt incorruptibile qͥdē eē ⁊ īdiſſolubile putamꝰ qͥdem exneceſſitate eſſe Accidit aūt ſcd̓m hāc rationē nōex neceſſitate natū. eſt em̄ vt cōtīgit eē motū maiorē ⁊ a quo qͥeſcit terra ⁊ a quo mouet̉ ignis ⁊qd̓ ſurſuꝫ corpꝰ. Siqͥdem igit̉ ſunt excedētesmotus diſſoluentur hec ab inuicem. Si veronō ſunt qͥdem. cōtīgūt aūt eē. Infinitū em̄ nōcōtīgit ꝓpter neqꝫ corpꝰ cōtingere infinitū eſſecōitgit itaqꝫ diſſolui celū Quid em̄ ꝓhibꝫ hocaccidere. ſiqͥdem nō impoſſibile Nō impoſſibile aūt ſi nō oppoſitū ncc̄ariū. Sed de hoc quidem dubio alter fit ſermoHic ꝯn̄r improbat hūc errorē duabꝰ ratōnibꝰ Quarūpͥª eſt. Si motor celi firmat̉ ad terrā in mouendo celū ẜmꝙ iſti dicunt ⁊ cū terra nō ſit aliqua ꝑs celi qd̓ mouet̉ ſeq̄ret̉ ꝙ fixū requiſitū ad motū celi nō ſit aliqua ꝑs eius. qd̓etſi verū ſit tn̄ contra eorū opinionē ē Pro ſcd̓a ratōe premittit quandā ꝓpoſitionē dicēs ꝙ quadocunqꝫ aliqd̓ mouens mouet aliqͥd innixū alicui fixo tūc in mouēdo oꝫ adequari ⁊ ꝓportionari virtutē mouētis in mouēdo. ⁊ qͥeſcētis in qͥeſcendo ẜm aliquā determinatā ꝓportionē. Mouens em̄ in mouēdo hꝫ determinatū vigorē ſeu ꝟtutemẜm quā mouet mobile. ⁊ ſil̓ter illud cui innitit̉ hꝫ quādādeterminatā virtutē in qͥeſcendo ẜm quā qͥeſcēs pōt figere mouēs. ⁊ eſt determinata q̄dā ꝓportio ꝟtutū mouētiūꝯͣ īuicē ⁊ qͥeſcētiū ẜm ꝙ īnixū qͥeſcēti p̄t mouere ⁊ ẜm quāfixū ⁊ qͥeſcens p̄t mouēs figere ⁊ ẜm quā p̄t mouere innixū qͥeſcenti ⁊ illud mouere. Si aūt mouēs īnixū qͥeſcēti ⁊mobile ⁊ vl̓r agentia ꝯtraria fuerīt oīno equata ſcd̓m ſuas ꝟtutes ẜm quas agunt ⁊ patiunt̉ īpoſſibile ē ꝙ vnū inalteruꝫ agat pͥº. qͣꝫuis poſſit in ip̄m agere ẜm ꝑtem. Sꝫſi debeat agere vnū in aliud oꝫ ꝙ excellat in ꝟtute. ẜm hoc

em̄ hͦ mouet. ⁊ illud mouet̉. ⁊ hͦ agit ⁊ illud patit̉. qd̓ agitexcedit in virtute. ⁊ qd̓ patit̉ excedit̉ Quandocūqꝫ gͦ mouens mouet aliqd̓ mobile. ꝑ hoc ꝙ innixū eſt alicui qͥeſcēti qͥeſcens illud erit maioris ꝟtutis in qͥeſcēdo qͣꝫ motorceli in mouēdo Illo gͦ ſic p̄miſſo arguit ad ꝓpoſitū ⁊ dicitPropt̓ hoc ſiue Atlas ſiue quodcūqꝫ moueat celū firmatū ad dexterū ſiue ad aliqͥd eorū que ſunt in terrā Qd̓ ītēdit ꝑ hoc ꝙ d̓t ꝙ ab his q̄ nō poſſunt eē maioris ꝟtutisin mouendo qͣꝫ terra ſit in manēdo Si em̄ ſit maioris virtutis in mouēdo terrā qͣꝫ terra in qͥeſcendo īpelleret eā exloco ſuo qm̄ ſicut hmōi mouēs pellit celū in mouēdo ip̄ꝫſic pellet terrā ⁊ ẜm ꝟtutē eius Ita ꝙ ſicut pellēs pellit ſicut qd̓ pellit̉. quare ſi Atlas ſit maioris ꝟtutis īpellit eāSed manifeſtū ē ꝙ pͥmū qd̓ mouet celū qͥeſcit. qꝛ ē oīnoīmobile. vt ꝓbatū eſt in octauo Phyſicoꝝ. quare ē maioris virtutis cū eo cui innitit̉. ⁊ verificat̉ diſiunctiua ꝓ altera ꝑte Sil̓ter oꝫ ip̄m habere maiorē virtutē in mouēdoqͣꝫ celū in qͥeſcēdo. Si ergo terra ſit illud cui firmat̉ in mouendo ipſam oꝫ eē maioris ꝟtutis in qͥeſcendo qͣꝫ ſit celū⁊ eius motor in mouendo Hoc aūt eſt īpoſſibile qꝛ ꝟtusterre ꝑ quam qͥeſcit eſt grauitas eius q̄ cauſat̉ a motu celiEt manifeſtū eſt motorē celi maioris ꝟtutis eſſe qͣꝫ ipſuꝫcelū. ⁊ celū totū qͣꝫ grauitas terre. ergo īpoſſibile eſt celuꝫmoueri ab aliquo motore firmato ad terraꝫ vel ad aliqd̓corporeū inter ip̄m exiſtēs Circa qd̓ ph̓s occaſione cuiuſdā iam dicti inducit quādā dubitationē. ⁊ pͥº tāgit ipſaꝫcū ratōe eius Scd̓o remouet rationē. Dicit gͦ ꝙ ex p̄cedētibꝰ poteſt accidere dubitatio q̄dā circa motū celi ⁊ ꝑtiūeius puta ſpherarū Quā dubitationē ſicut cōueniētē velcōſequētē ad ea que dicta ſunt prius pōt aliqͥs ꝯſiderareꝙ ſi motor celi firmatus ad terram in mouēdo excederetterrā in qͥeſcendo vt ſuppoſitū eſt. manifeſtū ē ꝙ mouebitipſam a medio Sicut ſi terra ad quā firmat̉ nauta. in mouendo. eſſet maioris ꝟtutis in qͥeſcendo qͣꝫ nauta in mouēdo moueret̉ terra Sic ē in ꝓpoſito. ſi motor celi firmatus ad terrā eēt maioris virtutis in mouēdo qͣꝫ terra inqͥeſcendo moueret terrā Non em̄ p̄t dici ꝙ terra ſit īfinitevirtutis in qͥeſcēdo ⁊ ideo nō mouetur a motore celi. ſiuemotor celi ſit finiteꝟtutis ſiue īfinite Terra em̄ qͥeſcit ꝓpt̓grauitatē eius. grauitas aūt eius finita ē qꝛ quātitas eiꝰfinita eſt quare virtus ꝓpter quaꝫ qͥeſcit terra. finita eſt.p̄t ergo moueri a maiori ꝟtute His aūt p̄miſſis remouꝫph̓us reſpōſionē quandā ad dictā dubitatōeꝫ Poſſet em̄aliqͥs dicere ꝙ motor celi firmatus ad terrā pōt ipſaꝫ mouere ex medio nunqͣꝫ tn̄ mouebit ipſaꝫ Et iō nō ſeqͥt̉ ꝙ celū nunquā corrūpat̉. Dicit ergo hac reſpōſionē remouendo ꝙ ſi aliqͥs ponat ꝙ motor celi non mouebit terrā. ⁊ ꝙnō erit maior motus qͣꝫ ſit. qͣꝫuis contingat ita eē. terra eiinfinita non eſt. ita vt moueri non poſſit. ſequet̉ gͦ ꝙ qͣꝫuisnō corrūpatur motꝰ eiꝰ ꝙ cōtingat ipſaꝫ corrūpi. ⁊ ſi cōtingat ipſaꝫ corrūpi. nihil ꝓhibet ipſam corruptā eē. ſi nōeſt īpoſſibile ipſam corrupi. nō ē aūt īpoſſibile ſi oppoſituꝫſcꝫ. ipſam eē. nō ſit neceſſariuꝫ Unde poſſibili poſito in eēnullū ſequit̉ īpoſſibile Sed de hac dubitatōe ſcꝫ Utrū celū ⁊ motus eius quādoqꝫ corrupāt̉ aut nō. alibi fit ſermoputa pͥº de celo ⁊ mūdo. ⁊ octauo phyſicorū.Utrum aūt oportet aliquid immobile eſſe ⁊quieſcēs extra id quod mouetur nulla pars illius exiſtēs aūt nō. Et hoc vtrum et in omni ſitexiſtere neceſſarium eſt.Poſtqͣꝫ ph̓s diſſoluit dubitationē quātū ad ſcd̓aꝫ ꝑtē

Q i