Topicoꝝ
quō rn̄dēdū eſt ſolutōe ẜm qͥd ibi (Eſt aūt orōeꝫ) Circapͥmū adhuc duo facit ph̓s. pͥmo docet rn̄tem ſoluere penes diuerſitatē pōnis ſcd̓o penes diuerſitatē interrogatoꝝ. ibi Qm̄ aūt) Circa primū. p. prīo p̄mittit q̄ ſiteiꝰ intētio ⁊ nccītas intētionis eiꝰ dicēs. ꝙ de rn̄ſione pͥmo qͥdē det̓mīandū eſt ſicꝭ qd̓ ſit opꝰ ꝓpriū int̓rogātis ſiue bn̄ opponētis ſup̄ det̓iatū ē. Eſt at opꝰ ꝓpriū ⁊ optiⁿinterrogātis in dialecticis ꝓut dialectica ē ad obuiatōnem talit̓ inducere orōem interrogatiuā id ē ſuā pōneꝫvt faciat rn̄tem īprobabiliſſima dicere. qꝛ aliter nō eſſetobuiatiua ⁊ īprobabiliora qͣꝫ ſtꝭ illa q̄ ꝓpt̓ pōem īprobabilē ſtꝭ nccāria hͦ eſt qͣꝫ ea q̄ ex ꝓbabili pone ſequunt̉. qͥaſicut opponētis ē obuiare rn̄ti. ita rn̄tis eſt obuiare opponēti. ita ꝙ nō videat̉ ꝓpt̓ ſuā rn̄ſionē accidere impoſſibile. aut inopīabile ſiue improbabile. ſꝫ ſi qͥd taliuꝫ accidit videat̉ accidere ꝓpt̓ pōnē īprobabilē quā ſuſtinet ſiue ſuſtinere vult. ex qͣpꝫ ꝙ nō eſt incōueīens rn̄tem aliqn̄ ponere pōnē īprobabilē ⁊ flām cū tn̄ eā ſuſtineat ſicꝙ nō ꝯcedat ꝯͣrīa ad eā ſꝫ neget repugnātia ⁊ ad imꝑtinētia rn̄deat ẜm eaꝝ qualitatemDiuerſum em̄ fortaſſe pctm̄ ponere p̄mūqd̓ nō oꝫ. ⁊ poſitū nō ſeruare ẜm modūHic. p. tāgit duo pctā rn̄tis pͥmū eſt ſi ponat id qd̓ n̄oꝫ in pōne ſua. ſcd̓m eſt ſi poſitū ē qd̓ oꝫ ſꝫ nō ſuſtinꝫ ip̄ꝫ ẜꝫmodū artꝭ dialectice .i. ẜm illū modū qͦ defendi dꝫ vel opꝫmodꝰ āt eſt vt ea q̄ ꝯſequunt̉ ad pōnem ꝯcedat. ⁊ q̄ repugnāt neget. qꝛ ex hoc fere orit̉ ſcia poſitionis. ſic igit̉ ptꝫquod eſt opus bene reſpondentisQm̄ aūt ſunt īfinita his qͥ ꝓpter gymnaſium vl̓ exꝑimentū rōcinatōis faciūt. nō eī cōſideratōes eedē ⁊ docētibꝰ ⁊ diſcētibꝰ ⁊ colluctātibus neqꝫ his ⁊ his qͥ exercēt ſe inuicē ꝑſpectōis cā. Nā diſcēti qͥdē ponēda ſtꝭ ſꝑ eaque vident̉. neqꝫ em̄ conat̉ vllus flm̄ dicereColluctātiū āt interrogantē qͥdem videri aliqͥd facere oꝫ oīno. rn̄tem aut nihil videri pati. In dialecticis āt ꝯuētōibꝰ his qͥ nō colluctatōis cā ſed exꝑimēti ⁊ ꝑſpectōis dubitationes faciūt nōdū enodatū eſt qͥd oporteatcōiecturare rn̄dentē. ⁊ qͣlia nō ad bn̄ ſeruandū pōnem. Qm̄ ergo nihil habemꝰ tradituꝫab alijs ip̄i aliqͥd tentemꝰ dicereHic ph̓s on̄t nccītatē huiꝰ det̓mīatōis dicens. ꝙ opbn̄ rn̄tis ē diuerſum ī diuerẜ diſputatōibꝰ. ⁊ gͣ oꝫ h̓ determīare ꝑ diſputatōis diuerſitatē ⁊ pōnis diſiūctōem. qͥainfinita ſtꝭ q̄ obſeruāda ſtꝭ rn̄ti his hͦ eſt ad hos diſputātes vel opponētes qͥ ꝑ gymnaſiū hͦ eſt luctā ⁊ certamenad obuiatōem diſputatōem faciūt. Et ſil̓r ītermīatū eſtqͥd rn̄ti obſeruādū ē ad eos qͥ faciūt rōcinatōes ⁊ diſputiones ꝓpt̓ exꝑimētū accipiendū de ꝟitate ꝓblematꝭ aſſignati vl̓ ꝯcl̓ois ſicꝭ facit dialecticꝰ inqͥſitiuꝰ. oꝑꝫ gͦ de iſtomētōem facere Quia nō eedē ꝯſideratōes obſeruāde indiſputādo docētibꝰ ſiue doctrīaliter diſputatibꝰ ⁊ diſcētibꝰ. hͦ ē inqͥſitīs ad exꝑimētū ꝟitatis ꝯcl̓onis. ⁊ colluctantibꝰ hͦ ē ad obuiatōeꝫ diſputātibꝰ vl̓ ſophiſtice. qꝛ dia-lecticꝰ obuiās aliqn̄ īduit formā ⁊ hītū ſophiſte p̄cipuein cautel̓. qͣꝫuis hͦ nōfaciat in finē deceptonis ꝑ locū ſo
phiſticum qͥ ē fall̓a Neqꝫ ē eadē ꝯſideratio in rn̄dēdo dialectice his qͥ ad exercitiū diſputāt exercētes ſe inuicē ideſt vt ꝑſpicatōes fiāt In oībꝰ em̄ his diuerſas ꝯſiderationes oꝫ hr̄e rn̄tes obſeruādo ſuū ꝓpriū opꝰ qd̓ ē nihil videri pati ꝑ opponentē. ⁊ ſi patiat̉ aliqͥd hͦ eſt ꝓpt̓ pōem.qꝛ ẜm modū ꝓpriū pōni hꝫ eā defendere hͦ ē ꝙ ꝯcedat qd̓eſt ex pōne ſequēs ⁊ nihil dicat pōni repugnās. Ars eīartifici tradita v̓tutē ꝯfert ad ꝓpriū opꝰ Ꝙ āt ꝯſiderationes diuerſe ſtꝭ obſeruāde ad diuerſimōe diſputantespatꝫ ex hͦ ꝙ diſcēti hͦ ē īqͥſitīe diſputāti ſꝑ ponēda ⁊ ꝯcedēda ſtꝭa rn̄te ea q̄ vidēt̉ eē ꝟa. qꝛ alit̓ nō adiuuat̉ ad ſuuꝫopꝰ ⁊ ad ſuū fini a ſocio a diſputāte. Nullꝰ em̄ diſcentiūaliqd̓ flm̄ dicere vl̓ perſuadere vult vt ſtet final̓r in iſto⁊ ſi ꝯcludat flm̄ ſicꝭ in ſyll̓o ad īpoſſibile ab illo redit ſtatim ad oppoſitū veꝝ. ⁊ ſtat in iſto ⁊ ſic rn̄s etꝭ ꝯcedensea q̄ vident̉ eſſe ꝟa nihil patit̉ ꝓpt̓ opponētē. ſꝫ ꝙ patit̉ ēꝓpt̓ pōnem. Alie āt ꝯſideratōes hn̄de ſtꝭrn̄ti colluctatīediſputāti ad obuiatōem. oꝫ em̄ aliqͥd facere videre ꝯtrarn̄tem eū qͥ colluctatīe diſputat. qͥ nō tm̄ intēdit ad pōeꝫdiſputare. ſꝫ plꝰ intēdit diſputare obuiādo rn̄ti. ⁊ rn̄tē etꝭad illū oꝫ hr̄e ad eū. vt nihil ab eo pati videat̉. ⁊ iō ad eūindiget cautel̓ ⁊ ꝯſideratōibꝰ cautelaꝝ In ꝯuētionibꝰ ātdialecticis qn̄ opponēs ꝯueīt rn̄tē ī his qͥdē q̄ nō colluctatōis cā. ſꝫ cā exꝑimēti hͦ eſt exꝑiēdi ꝑ ſyll̓ꝫ ⁊ rōcinatōeꝫet cā ꝑſpectōis .i. vt ꝑſpicatōes fiāt diſputatōes faciuntnōdū ab aliqͦ artifice ē enodatū qͥd cōſiderādo oporteatcōiecturare rn̄tē ⁊ qͣlia oꝫ eū nō dare ſiue negare ad poſitōem obſeruandā quā ẜm ꝓpriū modū ⁊ opꝰ oꝫ obſeruare rn̄tem vt dcm̄ eſt. ⁊ qꝛ de hͦ nihil certū habemꝰ tradituꝫqd̓ conueniens ſit oꝫ ꝙ noſip̄i tentemus aliquid de hoctradendo aliquam artemNeceſſe āt ſuſtinere orōem ponētē aut obabilē aūt īprobabilē pōem aūt neutrā. Eſtaūt ſimpl̓r ꝓbabilē vl̓ īprobabilē aut īdefinite. vt huic alicui vl̓ eidē Nihil āt dr̄t quolibꝫmō ꝓbabil̓ aūt īprobabilis ſit. nā idē modꝰerit bn̄ rn̄dēdi. ⁊ dādi vel nō dādi qd̓ īterrogatū ē. Nā cū improbabilis ē poſitio. nccē ēcōcluſionē fieri ꝓbabilē. cū ꝟ̓o ꝓbabilis imꝓbabilē. nā oppoſitū ſꝑ poſitōi interroganscōcludet Si at neqꝫ ꝓbabile neqꝫ improbabile qd̓ poſitū ē ⁊ cōcluſio erit talis.Hic ph̓s ꝯn̄r occaſione eoꝝ q̄ dcā ſtꝭ diuidit pōnem.eo ꝙ modꝰ rn̄dēdi ẜm diuerſitatē ponis variat̉ dicēs ꝙtripl̓x ē poſitio .ſ. ꝓbabil̓ improbabil̓ ⁊ neutra. q̄ alicui ꝓbabil̓ eſt. ⁊ alicui īprobabil̓. vl̓ q̄ nec videt̉ nec non videt̉Et ſb̓dīdit ph̓s pōnem ꝓbabilē dicēs ꝙ illa vl̓ ē ſimpl̓iꝓbabil̓ vl̓ ſimpl̓r imꝓbabil̓ aut indefinite ſiue indet̓minate medio mō ſe hn̄s. vl̓ huic qͥdeꝫ alicui ꝓbabil̓ vl̓ alijcuicūqꝫ ſcꝫ ip̄i opponēti vl̓ ip̄i rn̄ti īprobabilis. Et nihildiffert quō ſit poſitio ꝓbabil̓ vl̓ improbabil̓. nā ideꝫ eſtmodꝰ bn̄ rn̄tis ⁊ dādi vl̓ nō dādi qd̓ bn̄ eſt interrogatuꝫab opponente qͦ ad hoc vt eaueat vt nihil videatur patiab opponente maxīe obuiāte. ⁊ tn̄ nihil dicat repugͣnspoſitioni. ⁊ hoc ꝓbat̉ ſic. Quia ſi poſitio fuerit ꝓbabil̓cōcluſio erit improbabil̓ ⁊ ecōtra. Quia opponens ſiueinterrogās obuiās ſꝑ conat̉ cōcludere oppoſitū poſitioni rn̄tis. ⁊ ergo ſi poſitio rn̄tis fuerit ꝓbabilis ꝯcluſio