QueſtioXXIII

tas. ⁊ ſic vna forma ſb̓alis eſſet ꝯͣria alteri. qd̓eſt ꝯͣ ph̓m qͥnto phiſicoꝝ qͥꝓbat ꝙ ad ſb̓aꝫ nōeſt motꝰ: qꝛ nihil eſt ſb̓e ꝯͣriū. Ite ꝯria nata ſūtfieri circa vnū ⁊ idē ſubiectu. ſi gͦ inter formasſb̓ales ſit ꝯͣrietas oporteret idē ſubiectum hreſucceſſiue diuerſas formas ſb̓ales qd̓ apparetꝯͣ ſenſū. Iteꝫ int̓ oīa ꝯͣria eſt mediū: ſꝫ int̓ om̄sformas ſb̓ales nō eſt mediū. gͦ ⁊cͣ. Itē cōmentator. v. metaphiſice cōmēto. vij. dic̄ ꝙ elementa nō agūt niſi ꝑ qͣlitates cuiuſmōi nō ſunt forme ſb̓ales. Sil̓r ſcd̓o de aīa dicit ꝙ aīa agit⁊ nutrit rōne qualitatꝭ ⁊ mediante qualitate.Cōtra iſtā opinionē. ſi īmediate agere nō cōpetit forme ſb̓ali: aut hͦ eſt rōe ꝑfectōis aut īꝑfectōis. nō rōe ꝑfectōis: qꝛ p̄t competere nobilioribꝰ puta deo ⁊ āgelis. nec rōe iīꝑfectōis: qͥap̄t cōpetere iꝑfectioribꝰ puta accūti. Iteꝫ ẜmph̓m. vij. metaphiſice oē ſil̓e ꝓducit̉ a ſil̓i: tūcſic. qn̄ eſt ꝓductio ꝑ modū ſil̓is: tūc ꝓductū aſſil̓atur ꝓducēti: ſꝫ ꝓductō forme ſb̓alis in gn̓atōe vniuoca eſt ꝑ modū ſil̓is: gͦ forma ſb̓alis ꝓducta aſſil̓atur forme ꝓducēti: ſꝫ nō aſſil̓at̉ niſi forme ſb̓ali ⁊ nō accn̄tali. gͦ ⁊cͣ. Itē qn̄ aliqͥseffectꝰ ſic ſe hꝫ ad aliquā rē ꝙ poſita illa re p̄tponi effectꝰ naturalit̓ ⁊ illa nō poſita nō p̄t poni effectꝰ. illa res hꝫ rōem cāe rctū illiꝰ effectꝰīmediate vel mediate. hͦ eſt ſatis euidēs: qꝛ effectꝰ ſufficiēter depēdet ex cā ⁊cͣ. ſꝫ poſita forma ignis cū calore p̄t aliqͥs alius ignis gn̄ari⁊ nō poſita forma ignis. ⁊ ſi calor nō ponaturnō p̄t gn̄ari ignis vt ptꝫ ad ſenſū ſi calor i igneſeparet̉ ⁊ agat in aquā nūqͣ gn̄abit ignē: ſꝫ tm̄calorē. gͦ ⁊c̄. Cōfirmat̉ ꝑ aīam vegetatiuā: qꝛ illa poſita cū calore p̄t aliqͥd nutriri: ⁊ poſito calore ſine aīa vegetatiua non pōt nutriri. gͦ ⁊cͣ.Itē oē nccͣrio reqͥſitū naturalit̓ ad alique effectū vl̓ eſt cā illiꝰ effectus īmediata vl̓ mediatagͦ cū aīa vegetatiua nccͣrio requirat̉ ad nutritōem vel eſt cā nutritōis mediata vl̓ īmediataſi mediata: tūc eſt tm̄ cā ꝯſeruās cāꝫ īmediatāin eſſe: ſꝫ ſi illa cā īmediata cōſeruet̉ ab alio puta a deo deſtructa alia cā ꝯſeruāte nihilominꝰp̄t ſeqͥ effectꝰ. ⁊ ꝑ ꝯn̄s deſtrucra vegetatiua adhuc poſſet fieri nutritio alicuiꝰ naturalis ꝑ ſolā formā accn̄talē. qd̓ falſum eſt. gͦ hꝫ rōeꝫ cauſe īmediate. Itē pluralitas nō ē ponenda ſineneceſſitate: ſꝫ poſitꝭ qͣlitatibꝰ qͥbuſcūqꝫ ſine formis ſubſtātialibꝰ nō p̄t gn̓ari ſubſtantia. gͦ adgn̄atōeꝫ ſubſtātie neceſſario ē ponere formasſb̓ales in gn̓abilibꝰ: ſꝫ ad cauſādū effectū vltracens eſſentiales non oportet neceſſario aliqͥdponere. gͦ ⁊cͣ. Itē dicit̉ cōiter ꝙ herba eſt virtualiter calida cū tamē ſit formaliter frigida⁊ vinū virtualiter calidū: ſꝫ hͦ nō eſt: qꝛ aliquaqualitas in iſtis pōt efficere: qꝛ nec frigiditas

nec humiditas. ergoip̄a ſubſtātia eoꝝ eſt cauſa īmediata frigiditatis ⁊ caliditatis. Et ſichabet̉ ꝙ ſubſtātia eſt freq̄nter pͥncipiū īmediatū effectiuū actōis ⁊ etiā accidēs aliquandoſed quando eſt ⁊ quando nō: recurrēduꝫ eſt vtcredo ad experiētiam quia ſi per experientiaꝫpoſſumꝰ cogſcere ꝙ ſola ſubſtātia poſita in effectu ⁊ ꝯſeruata p̄t effectū ꝯſeruare ⁊ cāre ſine oī accn̄te a ꝑte pͥncipij elicitiui ibi ſola ſb̓aeſt cā īmediata effectꝰ ꝯcurrēs tn̄ cū deo. ſi autē exꝑiamur ꝙ effectꝰ p̄t cāri a ſolo accn̄te ſineſb̓a tūc eſt cā imediata nō ſb̓a ſi aūt nō p̄t cauſari ſine vtroqꝫ: tūc vtrūqꝫ eſt cāꝑtialis rctū illius effectꝰ. ⁊ hͦ eſt gn̓aliter verū in om̄i actōenaturali. Tenēdo igit̉ iſtā ꝯcluſionē p̄t rn̄de-ri ad rōes alterius opinionis. Ad primā dico1ꝙ maior videt̉ falſa ⁊ dubia ⁊ minor ſil̓r. Maior: qꝛ nō eſſe corruptiuū vniꝰ forme eſt ꝓductiuū forme ſibi incōpoſſibilis: tū qꝛ deus p̄t coagere forme in corrūpēdo nō coagēdo ſibi in ꝓducēdo: tū qꝛ caritas ⁊ odiū dei formaliter repugnāt ⁊ volūtas p̄t corrūpere odiuꝫ dei ⁊ tn̄nō pōt ꝓducere caritatē: qꝛ a ſolo deo infunditur: tū qꝛ volūtas p̄t auertere intellectū ab oīactu intelligendi prima principia: ⁊ ſic corrupere habitu primoꝝ pͥncipioꝝ nō tn̄ pōt ꝓducere habitū erroris circa pͥma pͥncipia: tu qꝛ ſicōcedit̉ maior particularit̓ ſumpta nō habet̉ꝓpoſitū: qꝛ nō ſequit̉. p̄t ꝓducere incōpoſſibilem formā forme corrupte: gͦ oēm formā: gͦ formā ſubſtātialē: ſꝫ eſt fallacia ꝯn̄tis: qꝛ ſi ſormaaccidētalis ſit ꝓductiua forme nō eſt ꝓductiua niſi tm̄ forme accn̄talis q̄ eſt incōpoſſibilisforme corrupte ſaltē ẜm certū gradum. minoretiā eſt dubia: tū qꝛ accipit ꝙ forme ſuſtātialesformalit̓ repugnāt. qd̓ videt̉ falſum: qꝛ illa ſūtformaliter repugnātia q̄ nata ſunt fieri circaidē ſubiectū. ptꝫ de caliditate ⁊cͣ. ſic nō eſt deformis ſubſtātialibus: qꝛ ꝑ corruptōem vniuscorrūpitur vnū ſubiectū ꝑ inductiōem alteriꝰgn̄̓at̉ alid̓ ſubiectū. ptꝫ de formis elemētaribꝰtū qꝛ qn̄ aliqͣ forma ꝓductiua eqͣlit̓ reſpicit ml̓ta nō eſt maior rō quare ꝓducit vnū ꝙͣ aliud: ſꝫfrigiditas equaliter reſpicit terrā ⁊ aquam: caliditas aerem ⁊ ignē. ſi ergo frigiditas ſit forma productiua ſubſtantie non eſt maior ratioquare producit formam terre ꝙͣ aque. ⁊ econuerſo. ſed illa cauſabit vtranqꝫ vel neutram.Iō dico ꝙ licet forma accidentalis ſit productiua: non tamen forme ſubſtantialis: ſed ſolum accidentalis incompoſſibilis forme ſubſtantiali corrūpende ẜm determinatum gradum: licet non ſit formalis repugnantia interformā ſubſtātialē ⁊ accn̄talē quācūqꝫ. ⁊ datoꝙ forma accidētalis eſſꝫ ꝓductiua ſb̓e adhuc

h v

Crmū

Lintumſpmmopi. pͥmaꝫ

Mpindum

ſpmmopi. pͥmaꝫ

Ad primā alterius opinionis

p